The prospectus, either for the.A. Now that Ive successfully defended my dissertation prospectus, I thought Id provide a few tips stemming from my own experience. Thesis and Dissertation Forms (English Dept. The aim is to convince the committee of the projects substance, significance, and philosophical fecundity. The introductory section offers many of the specific argument moves in miniature, within and against the literature, which will be developed and expanded by the empirical evidence collected during the research process. The advisor works with the committee to schedule a proposal defense date. Length: 20 25 pages of text, including a working bibliography, chapter outline, and timeline for completing the work. The prospectus will be sent for evaluation to one or two scholars outside the department.
Introduction sets the stage by identifying a lack of conversation and dissonance among scholarly discussions from Writing Center studies, Composition Pedagogy, professionalization literature, and pedagogical practices when she chose to focus on the lived professional and educational experiences of graduate student tutor / teachers. Bibliography: The student need not have read all of the sources listed in the Bibliography. Rememberexperts in your field believe in you enough to be on your committee. Chapter Outline reminds us that the dissertation will take on scholarship throughout as it builds an argument based on the evidence collected about graduate student tutor/teachers. Writing the prospectus will be your foremost task during the first year of doctoral studies. Graduate Studies Office resources dissertation prospectus defense for Thesis Dissertation Writing (list compiled by WPA-listserv what is the Prospectus? The prospectus is a proposal for dissertation research written under the supervision of a member of the doctoral faculty who is willing to sponsor. Now I feel more confident that, no matter what happens next, my committee will be behind. Youve done a lot of work, and youve spent a lot of time thinking about this topic, but in grad school it can be hard to feel like an expert. You may be asked to rework your proposal (only once) and/or acquire some additional skills necessary for your work before being admitted to doctoral candidate status.
Foreign Language and Research Techniques While the Philosophy Program has no general language requirement, the prospectus examination committee will determine whether a students proposed dissertation topic will require that the student be able to read material in a foreign language. It will not be graded (i.e., pass/fail). Two of the members of this committee, including the Supervisor, must be on the GC philosophy faculty; one may come from another GC program or another university. Only after all committee members agree that the proposal is defendable, can an oral defense of the dissertation proposal be scheduled. In contrast, my committee was respectful and encouraging.
The committee will then have a minimum of 3 weeks to read the revised proposal and decide if this version warrants a defense. Further, this study seeks to establish that a greater depth of professional development occurs when graduate students embody spaces of teaching and tutoring, as opposed to embodying one or the other throughout their graduate experience. For examplein my defense, my committee raised the objection that my empirical cases seem more like separate projects than one coherent project. The prospectus must be circulated at least one week prior to the examination. The prospectus examination should be taken by the end of the second semester following advancement to candidacy for the student to maintain satisfactory progress. What you hope to discover, presented as a thesis statement or a hypothesis. Your committee knows youre not perfect. The student will work with their adviser and will resubmit to the committee a revised proposal. Many projects use a mix of specific methods and draw upon specific inspirational sources as models. Defense of the dissertation prospectus : The dissertation prospectus defense is a public examination, held before your. I emphasize it again nowyour committee wants to help you. The Dissertation Committee The student and Supervisor must contact the Executive Officer within two weeks of having passed the prospectus examination to discuss the formation of the three-person dissertation supervisory committee.
Talk about the strengths of your project and how it contributes to existing research. While the length of the prospectus may vary, a maximum of 8,000 words of text plus ve to eight pages of bibliography will usually do justice to the task. When there is mutual agreement about the project the faculty member will notify the Executive Officer. Failing to do so will not give committee members adequate time to read, comment, and approve moving forward with the dissertation defense before the Graduate School deadline. The Introductory chapter will answer the broad research questions by using a literature review as well as some of the research results. The prospectus proper must contain: Title: The proposed title of the dissertation ; students name; dissertation supervisor. Sure, they elected to be on your committee, which shows they already believe in you.
Dissertation, prospectus, defense, committee (i.e., your supervisor and two resident or recurrent visiting professors plus one external examiner, who may or may not be present on this occasion; if absent s/he will send his/her comments in writing with the. In another post, I mentioned my anxiety about the Q A portion of the defense. I very openly expressed these ambiguities and contingencies to my committee. In the case of failure, the committee may also decide whether or not the student may submit a new prospectus on the same topic. Once the Sponsor believes dissertation prospectus defense that the prospectus is ready for examination, they, in consultation with the student, will submit to the Executive Officer for approval the names of the appropriate and willing faculty members to serve on the examination committee. Be your foremost task during the first year of studies.
Setting Up the Prospectus Examination An oral examination is scheduled to test the proposal and the students capacity to undertake. Dissertation Content The usual dissertation is constructed like a monograph or book, treating an approved topic in some depth. It is part of the responsibility of the entire supervisory committee to monitor the progress of the student. The Assistant Program Officer will email a description of the responsibilities of a committee member to the individual members, who will confirm their willingness to serve by return email to the Assistant Program Officer. This plan can be as detailed as the writer or committee thinks is necessary. Nota bene: At the discretion of your provisional supervisor, a written unseen translation paper in the main source language or one of the main source languages necessary to pursue your dissertation project successfully, may be part of the prospectus defense. The student is not present at this meeting. The account must demonstrate how these theories are connected to the topic as well as show how methodologies are connected to the data being used; a tentative outline; an exhaustive research bibliography specifying literature that has been, or will be, consulted. The committee decides to move forward with the proposal defense ; the student makes revisions required by the committee, preferably provided to the student in a written summary based on the discussion at the meeting.
It ought instead to include all of the sources the student believes will prove relevant to the project. The Defense When the three-person supervisory committee is satisfied that the dissertation is ready for defense, each member emails the Assistant Program Officer to register his/her approval. Introduction: Why this research is important or necessary. Then name your specific methods for analysis and/or data collection. Outcomes of the Prospectus Examination The prospectus examination can have any one of three outcomes. Heres where we find a specific statement of what the writer is planning to find, stated as hypotheses that will tested and proven by the data collected: I believe these questions will lead me to find that graduate students. Statement of thesis: In 1,000-2,000 words, this section states and motivates the project. Focus of the project and / or specific research questions addressed by the research. In a previous post, I mentioned the importance of seeing the defense as a chance to talk about your research with smart people, instead of a test you must pass. Note: This pre- defense meeting is a change from our previous policy.
Methodology: How do you plan to conduct the research? It describes the present state of the issue, indicating the major positions in a debate and where possible cites the most important literature. The committee decides not to move forward with the proposal defense ; if this is the outcome, then the process restarts. The writers strategy is an organic one, with the literature discussed throughout her argument, that then forces scholars to talk to one another in a kind of musical retuning into counterpoint harmony. The writer then moved into describing the specific methods, which are the specific tools for empirical and ethnographic teacher research: surveys, interviews, teaching portfolios and observations. Once the three-person supervisory committee has been appointed, the Executive Officer will notify the Assistant Program Officer of the names of the committee. The student may alternatively opt for a dissertation composed of three substantial essays on approved topics specifically dissertation prospectus defense constructed for the dissertation. They noted that the cases dont perfectly align with the overall theory. Chapter Outline: Parse out the sections of the dissertation project based on specific texts, theoretical frameworks, themes, or topics to be addressed. After months of thinking, I identified some common, core themes that emerged from my projects and tried to design a dissertation around those. Faculty are given a minimum of three weeks to read the document and give feedback, preferably in writing. This sample should be around 5,000 words long.
The committee may designate an outstanding performance with a special grade of Pass with Honors on the dissertation and/or the defense. Describe theoretical frameworks or the philosophy that underlies your methods. Some projects separate the sources into sections that indicate which sources supports specific themes, topics or methods. Methodology makes the case for lore as a flexible, experience-based, narrative dissertation prospectus defense methodology and takes on the scholarly debates about lores value and how it supports the goals of the project to examine reflection and reflexivity in more fluid, community-based ways. If you demonstrate gratefulness for their time and willingness to reform your project, you will set a positive tone for your committee. I expected my committee would take an adversarial tone. Each of your committee members agreed to be on your committee because they believe in you. The process outlined above is the same, with one exception.
You set the tone for your defense. Together with the comprehensive exam, the dissertation prospectus defense will mark the end of your period as a probationary doctoral student and your promotion to the status of doctoral candidate. The grades are: Pass, Pass with minor revisions, Pass with major revisions, Fail. This ones a toughie. The proposal documents the proposed lines of argument organized in a logically developed order. Dissertation, is a written plan for the research the student intends to complete. Dissertation, prospectus, the final version of the, dissertation, prospectus is due by the end of the Winter Semester in order to allow external and internal adjudication and an oral defense during the Spring Semester.
This chapter and all the subsequent chapters are driven by specific research questions that have data collection tools associated with them. If a student must change or replace any committee member, including the Supervisor, the student should speak with the Executive Officer and the Assistant Program Officer as soon as possible. This document can be (all or part of) a paper written dissertation prospectus defense for publication, or (all or part of) a Qualifying Paper, or a paper written for a course. Sponsor, the student will consult with a faculty member about sponsoring a dissertation project. Your stance and voice dominate the entire discussion, including the literature review. Working Bibliography: List the sources that directly support the literature review and models for your methodology, but include everything consulted at this point, not just those cited in the prospectus. Selection from dissertation : Together with the summary, the student will submit a draft of one section of the dissertation.
Thats not news to them. Instead of viewing my committee members as meanies trying to test or insult me, I saw them as partners in my quest to be successful. Ten minutes followed by pertinent questions regarding your dissertation prospectus defense proposed research topics and the specific way you addressed it in your prospectus. I genuinely wanted to make my project better, and I appreciated the opportunity to learn from them. That is a powerful statement! Explanation from a Sample Dissertation Prospectus. After a successful defense, students submit a, conflict of Interest Form along with the, prospectus and Record of Approval Form. I am not sure whether Ill gain access to certain data.
If students wish to graduate the same term they defend their dissertation, students must deliver a full draft of the written work to all committee members at least six weeks before the last day to defend in the semester in which they graduate. Students should work with their dissertation adviser to finalize their proposal. It may well be that the student has worked out some part in greater detail, while conceiving another part more sketchily. The Oral Defense (for dissertations In a separate document, outline your talking points, select visuals or other examples, and anticipate challenges during the research process. In my own experience, the defense was not nearly as scary as fabled. A tentative writing schedule will be discussed so that the committee knows how the project will proceed and who will read which sections. So help them help you by being honest with them about your current status, your concerns about the project, and your thinking in general. The Supervisor, in consultation with the student, will submit to the Executive Officer for approval the names of two appropriate and willing faculty members to serve on the three-person committee. A passing mark on the prospectus exam shall be awarded only if a simple majority of committee members assent. Both the Supervisor and the student should be sure dissertation prospectus defense that completed chapters or sections of the thesis are regularly submitted to the other two members of the committee so they may comment on them (if necessary or desirable) and.
The defense doesnt have to be an argument between opposing sides; it can become a collaborative conversation about how to make your project the best it can. Project proposal: The plan for the dissertation, in 2,000-3,000 words, stating the method for resolving the central question or problem dissertation prospectus defense that is the topic of the dissertation. Once the adviser approves the draft, the proposal is sent to the entire dissertation committee for review. The proposal is a template or advertisement for the thesis, more like a grant application than like a qualifying paper, a journal article, or an introductory chapter. The maximum length of the combined documents will be 10,000 words (not including the bibliography).
Both the feasibility of the proposed dissertation project and your ability to complete it (research skills, familiarity with scholarly issues for the context of the dissertation, etc.) will be assessed. But note that the examination committee must include three graduate center faculty. Rather than getting defensive or trying to argue, I explained that this disjointed feeling may stem from the fact that each project began as its own, separate entity. Despite all the honesty and receptiveness to criticism, your committee is also looking for confidence. When my committee members gave me criticism, I didnt get defensive; instead, I welcomed the opportunity to improve my project.
It will set any requirements that need to be satisfied dissertation prospectus defense for the approval of the dissertation. Literature Review: Much of the prospectus should review the scholarly literature, whether divided into topical / thematic sections or as an ongoing discussion from theory to application, specific analyses to general reception, historical contexts to specific texts, or another organizational structure. In consultation with his/her faculty adviser, the student organizes. Prospectus, committee which will normally consist of 3 faculty members, but no fewer than. Preparing and Defending the. Dissertation Prospectus, admission to candidacy for the.